Our Weight is Lifted: The OHWM Online

The folks over at Oxford University Press (OUP) recently rolled out the latest component in the OHWM ecosystem: an online version of Taruskin’s complete text, accessible through a institutional or individual subscription. A few weeks ago, the people over at OUP gave me advance access to the database, which allowed me to poke around and ponder some of the advantages and potential disadvantages of this new iteration of the OHWM.

The first advantage is perhaps the most obvious: it makes the OHWM portable. “Portable” is definitely not a word used to describe the series up to now. Virtually every story written about Taruskin’s opus has mentioned its formidable size, this blog included (more than once).  My non-virtual edition (that is, the paperback one) of the OHWM lives at home, and I almost never take it with me to school or class, for practical reasons. I certainly have never taken the entire set out of the house at once. There have been several times over the last year when, in the final preparations for teaching a music history class, I suddenly think of something in the OHWM that would go perfectly in the lecture. Whereas before I would have to file it away “for next time,” having access to this database anywhere, anytime, could bring more of those potential teaching moments to immediate reality.

The second advantage I noticed was the searching capability, which allows the reader to investigate conceptual threads throughout all volumes. Search “passus duriusculus,” for instance, and you immediately get an at-a-glance perspective of this rich concept’s pervasive presence in Taruskin’s history.

From my limited interaction with the site (my preview access has expired), it seems like a fairly straightforward porting of the text from page to screen, with only a few bells and whistles. The pages are parsed out by section (rather than chapter), so that the text comes in relatively small chunks, equivalent to a few “real” pages at a time. All musical examples and images are incorporated into the flow of the text (with a handy “Art Credits” link). Though each entry is placed within the flow of the overall text via the table of contents sidebar, the interface encourages various reading experiences other than the traditional linear one. You can skip around, search key terms, or click on the related links to outside material from Grove Music Online. While I can see some benefits of these alternate strategies, I can’t help but feel that the overall narrative and argumentative arc of the history, which Taruskin has crafted so consistently and skillfully, will be lost on more casual users of the site.

One opportunity that I would like to see pursued is the development of even more interconnectivity with Oxford Music Online. Currently, Taruskin’s sections link to Grove online, but it doesn’t look like that connection is a two-way one. It would be nice, with a single search, to receive results from Grove Music Online, the Oxford Companion to Music, the Oxford Dictionary Online, and the OHWM. I don’t know if this is even possible (for legal reasons) or ultimately desirable (for philosophical ones), but the prospect is a tantalizing one. I can easily imagine a distinct benefit for the end user.

In my opinion, the best way to experience the OHWM is to read it straight through, on paper. This is the way Taruskin conceived of it, and his writing shows that he took the long-form medium seriously. I also see the immense practicality the digital OHWM will bring to its current readers, and the increased dissemination of the material to potential readers. In other words, I like both; I want both. Can I have my cake and eat a virtual version of it too?

But now I ask you: If you had access to this database, how/when/why would you use it? Would you do all your reading on the site, or only when you were away from your paper copy? If you don’t own a paper copy, would you feel a need to buy one given that it’s all there online?

6 Comments

  1. I bring in tidbits from the OHWM (and this blog!) to my music theory class from time to time. If I get the music history sequence after the current music history instructor fully retires, I’ve been contemplating using the OHWM as a major resource for said course. Obviously, the two largest hesitations I had about doing so are the size (I’d only assign portions of the various chapters for undergrads to read) and the cost. If my undergrads are able to access the OHWM via our subscription to Oxford Music Online, suddenly I have zero qualms about drawing upon the OHWM for said potential future undergrad music history sequence as a supplement to a less expensive, more basic music history text. I think exposing the undergrads to some of the discussions in the Taruskin will really open their eyes up to how much more there is to musicology than just dates, composers, and their works, possibly leading some of them to decide this would be an interesting vocation for them to pursue.

  2. Good point Nathan. This would be a great supplementary resource for a class. Keep your eyes peeled for the OHWM ecosystem to expand even more though: I’ve heard credible rumors that a textbook version of the OHWM (geared towards undergraduate music history courses) will be released in the future…

  3. It’s no mere rumor, about a one-volume condensation/adaptation of RT’s 6 vols. OUP wrote to a number of people asking for comments on a possible title for the textbook.

    There’s a lot of excitement about the textbook version.

    But this online access to the full version is, I agree, at least as intriguing–full of different pedagogical uses……..

    I imagine I’ll still prefer to sit and read from the 6 volumes, which I have in paperback. Reading online tends to encourage a kind of jumpiness that negates some of the coherent flow that RT has built into his book(s) so wonderfully and thought-provokingly.

  4. Ralph—I got that email survey about the textbook title. I’m very interested to see how all that works out, and to see how they position OHWM (or whatever they end up calling it) in the undergrad textbook market.

  5. I’ve been hoping that OUP would make Taruskin’s series available in PDF format for sale, hopefully free of DRM (copy protection) the way that O’Reilly does for its books (http://oreilly.com/ebooks/). That way, I’d be able to read the series for its long form narrative while still being able to search the text (and actually compute on it.)

  6. Attractive part of content. I just stumbled upon your website and
    in accession capital to assert that I get actually enjoyed account your blog posts.
    Any way I will be subscribing on your augment and even I achievement
    you get right of entry to constantly quickly.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s